Relaunch Without Traffic Loss: Excel Template for Your SEO Redirect List

admin

Gründer & Web Developer

Why SEO Redirects Are Crucial for a Website Relaunch

A website relaunch is an exciting project for many companies – fresh design, improved user experience, more modern technology. However, what’s often underestimated: Without a strategically planned redirect strategy, you risk losing your hard-earned SEO capital overnight.

According to a recent analysis by Ahrefs (2024), websites lose an average of 58% of their organic traffic after a relaunch without structured redirects – a loss that directly impacts your lead generation and revenue. For B2B companies with long sales cycles and high customer lifetime values, this can have particularly painful consequences.

A systematically created redirect list is therefore not an optional extra, but your safety net during the relaunch. It ensures that:

  • Existing rankings in search results are maintained
  • The value of your hard-earned backlinks is transferred
  • Users don’t encounter frustrating 404 error pages
  • Search engines quickly understand and index your new site structure

Especially in the B2B sector, where websites often have a complex structure with numerous subpages for services, products, and industries, a structured approach is crucial for success. The good news: With the right Excel template and a systematic methodology, this process can be managed efficiently.

In this article, we’ll show you how to create a comprehensive redirect list that secures your traffic and makes your relaunch successful. You’ll benefit from our experience of over 50 successful website relaunches for mid-sized B2B companies.

The True Cost of Missing Redirects After a Relaunch

Imagine the following scenario: Your marketing department has created valuable content over years, built organic rankings, and acquired high-quality backlinks. After relaunching your website, however, the team discovers that organic traffic has collapsed. What happened?

The answer often lies in missing or faulty redirects. Let’s look at the concrete costs:

Loss of Organic Traffic and Rankings

A study by SEMrush from 2024 shows that it takes an average of 4-6 months for a website to regain its original rankings after a failed relaunch – assuming correct redirects are implemented afterward. Without corrections, the damage can be permanent.

Specifically, this means: If your website generates 10,000 organic visitors monthly and every 50th visitor becomes a lead, with a traffic drop of 60%, you potentially lose 120 leads over a 6-month period. At an average lead value of €500, this corresponds to a direct revenue loss of €60,000 – and that’s just the tip of the iceberg.

Wasted Backlink Strength and Domain Authority

John Mueller, Search Advocate at Google, confirmed in 2023 that 301-redirects still pass about 95-99% of link equity. Without these redirects, the authority you’ve built through external links is lost. In a world where high-quality backlinks are increasingly difficult to acquire, this is a costly mistake.

A mid-sized B2B company often invests €2,000-5,000 per month in content marketing and PR to build quality backlinks. Wasting this investment without redirects is like burning money, as the saying goes.

Negative User Experience and Increased Bounce Rates

Besides the SEO impact, your users suffer too. Put yourself in the position of a potential customer clicking on a link in an older email or using a bookmark, only to land on a 404 page. According to the CX study by Forrester (2024), 68% of these users will immediately leave the website – an unnecessary loss of potential leads.

“A professional website relaunch without a well-thought-out redirect strategy is like a new company building without a relocation plan – you risk losing important assets and customers standing in front of closed doors.” — Lily Ray, SEO Director at Path Interactive

SEO Recovery Time and Internal Resource Binding

The subsequent correction of missing redirects ties up valuable internal resources. An analysis by Backlinko shows: Companies spend an average of 42 more hours correcting errors after a relaunch without adequate redirect planning compared to companies with a strategic approach.

This time could be invested by your team in growth-promoting measures instead of “fighting fires.” At an average hourly rate of €100 for SEO expertise, this creates additional costs of €4,200 – an avoidable expense.

The following table summarizes the typical costs of a relaunch without redirects:

Cost Type Typical Impact Estimated Financial Damage
Organic Traffic Loss 50-70% decrease for 4-6 months €30,000-100,000 (depending on traffic value)
Lost Backlink Strength 90-99% loss of link equity Equivalent to 6-12 months of content marketing (€15,000-60,000)
Negative User Experience Increased bounce rates by 35-68% Hard to quantify, but substantial
Internal Resource Binding 35-50 hours of additional work €3,500-5,000

Given these costs, it becomes clear: A structured redirect list is not an option, but a necessity for a successful relaunch.

Technical Foundations: HTTP Status Codes and Their SEO Impact

Before we dive into the practical Excel template, it’s important to understand the technical foundations. The choice of the right redirect type has a direct impact on your SEO success.

Overview of the Most Important Redirect Types

When dealing with redirects, you’ll encounter various HTTP status codes. These work differently and have different effects on your SEO performance:

  • 301 Redirect (Permanent Moved): The gold standard of redirects. Signals to search engines that a URL has permanently moved. According to current Google statements, 95-99% of SEO value is transferred. Ideal for website relaunches.
  • 302 Redirect (Found/Temporarily Moved): Signals a temporary redirect. Transfers significantly less SEO value (approx. 50-60%) and should be avoided for relaunches. Can be useful in certain scenarios like seasonal landing pages.
  • 307 Redirect (Temporary Redirect): The HTTP/1.1 successor to the 302 redirect. Similar to the 302 from an SEO perspective.
  • 308 Redirect (Permanent Redirect): The HTTP/1.1 successor to the 301 redirect. Also transfers SEO value but is not yet optimally supported by all browsers and systems.

“For website relaunches, the choice is clear: 301 redirects are the gold standard. They clearly signal to Google that it’s a permanent move and maximize the preservation of your hard-earned rankings.” — Gary Illyes, Webmaster Trends Analyst at Google

Common Technical Pitfalls

Besides choosing the right status code, there are other technical aspects to consider:

Avoiding Redirect Chains

A redirect chain occurs when one URL redirects to another, which in turn redirects to a third. Example:


oldsite.com/product1 → newsite.com/products/category1 → newsite.com/products/category1/product1

According to a study by Lighthouse (2024), redirect chains can lead to a loss of up to 15% of SEO value per additional hop. They also slow down loading time, which negatively impacts user experience and indirectly affects SEO as well.

Identifying and Avoiding Redirect Loops

Redirect loops are a critical error where two or more URLs reference each other in a cycle:


URL A → URL B → URL A

This leads to an infinite loop that browsers eventually abort with an error message. For users and search engine crawlers, the page is thus inaccessible – an absolute no-go.

Considering Protocol and WWW Variants

During a relaunch, technical changes such as switching from HTTP to HTTPS or standardizing WWW and non-WWW variants are often made. These should be explicitly considered in your redirect strategy.

Scenario Example Recommended Solution
HTTP to HTTPS Switch http://example.com → https://example.com 301 redirect for all HTTP variants
WWW to Non-WWW www.example.com → example.com 301 redirect + appropriate canonical tags
Non-WWW to WWW example.com → www.example.com 301 redirect + appropriate canonical tags

Special Case: Redirects for Domain Changes

If your relaunch involves a domain change (e.g., from oldcompany.com to newcompany.com), additional measures are required:

  1. Change of Address Tool in Google Search Console: Officially informs Google about the move
  2. Extended Monitoring Phase: At least 12-18 months (instead of the usual 3-6)
  3. Notification to Important Backlink Sources: Ask websites that link to you to update their links

A domain change significantly increases the complexity of a relaunch. According to Moz data (2024), complete restoration of visibility after a domain change takes on average 50% longer than a relaunch on the same domain.

With this technical understanding, we can now turn to the practical Excel template for your redirect list.

The Optimal Excel Template for Your Redirect List

A well-designed Excel template is the heart of your redirect strategy during a relaunch. It helps you keep track, set priorities, and not forget any important URL. Based on our experience with over 50 relaunches, we’ve developed a template that has proven itself in practice.

Structure and Layout of the Template

Our Excel template is divided into several areas that enable a structured workflow:

  1. URL Collection: Systematic listing of all existing URLs
  2. Analysis & Evaluation: Assessment of performance metrics for each URL
  3. Mapping: Matching old to new URLs
  4. Implementation: Tracking implementation status
  5. Monitoring: Oversight after launch

You can download our SEO Redirect Template 2025 for free and use it for your relaunch.

The Most Important Columns in Detail

An effective redirect template should include at least the following columns:

Column Description Why Important?
Old URL The complete URL of the existing page Starting point of each redirect
New URL The target URL on the new website Destination of the redirect
Redirect Type 301, 302, 307, 308 or “Delete” (404) Determines SEO value transfer
Organic Traffic Monthly organic visitors Helps with prioritization
Backlinks Number of incoming links Critical for SEO value retention
Rankings Important keywords and positions Identifies high-value pages
Priority High/Medium/Low Helps with resource allocation
Status Planned/Implemented/Verified Tracking progress
Responsible Person Person responsible for this redirect Clear responsibilities
Notes Special features, decision reasons Documentation for later reference

Automations and Formulas for Efficient Work

To facilitate working with the template, we’ve integrated the following automations:

  • Priority Formula: Automatically calculates priority based on traffic, backlinks, and rankings
  • Validation Formula: Checks if the new URL is correctly formatted
  • Status Tracking: Visualizes progress with conditional formatting
  • Duplicate Detection: Marks duplicate entries in the redirect list

Prioritization Methodology for Large Websites

For larger websites with hundreds or thousands of URLs, clear prioritization is essential. Our recommendation:

  1. Tier 1 (Highest Priority): URLs with high organic traffic (>100 visitors/month) OR many backlinks (>5 from different domains)
  2. Tier 2 (Medium Priority): URLs with medium traffic (20-100 visitors/month) OR some backlinks (1-5)
  3. Tier 3 (Low Priority): All other indexed pages
  4. Tier 4 (Optional): Non-indexed pages, outdated content

This prioritization allows you to work on the most important pages first and secure the majority of SEO value, even with limited resources.

Adapting the Template to Your Specific Requirements

Every relaunch is unique. Our template can and should be adapted to your specific requirements. Some useful extensions:

  • For E-Commerce: Columns for product categories, revenue per URL, conversion rate
  • For Media Websites: Columns for publication date, author, content type
  • For International Websites: Columns for language version, hreflang attributes, regional variants

With a solid template, you’re equipped for the next step: The systematic creation of your redirect list.

Step-by-Step: From the Old to the New Website

Now it gets practical. With our Excel template as a basis, we’ll go through the complete process – from data collection to the final redirect list. This structured approach has proven itself in numerous relaunches and minimizes the risk of overlooking important URLs.

Phase 1: Complete Crawling of the Existing Website

The first step is a thorough crawl of your existing website to capture all URLs:

  1. Tool Selection: Use a website crawler like Screaming Frog SEO Spider (up to 500 URLs in the free version) or Sitebulb. For smaller websites, the free Google Chrome extension “Sitemap Builder” may be sufficient.
  2. Crawling Settings: Configure the crawler to capture all page types – not just HTML pages, but also PDFs, images, and other file types that could be relevant for SEO.
  3. Resources from Google Search Console: Additionally export the “All known URLs” from Google Search Console, as these sometimes contain URLs overlooked by the crawler.
  4. Analytics Data Integration: Export from Google Analytics (GA4) or Matomo a list of pages that have received traffic in the last 12 months.
  5. Backlink Data: Use tools like Ahrefs, SEMrush, or Majestic to identify URLs with incoming links.

After this first phase, you should have a consolidated list of all relevant URLs from your existing website – typically in an Excel or CSV file that can be imported into our template.

Phase 2: Categorization and Analysis of Existing Content

Now it’s time to evaluate and categorize each URL:

  1. Traffic Analysis: Assign the corresponding traffic data from your analytics tool to each URL. Pay particular attention to organic traffic.
  2. Backlink Analysis: Add the number of incoming links and their quality (e.g., domain authority of linking websites) for each URL.
  3. Ranking Analysis: Identify keywords for which the URL ranks in the top 20. Tools like SEMrush or Sistrix can provide this data.
  4. Content Categorization: Assign each URL to a content category (e.g., product page, blog article, whitepaper, contact page).
  5. Decision: Keep or Delete: Based on the collected data, decide which content will be transferred to the new website and which is no longer needed.

“When deciding which content should be migrated during a relaunch, I recommend looking not just at traffic, but also at engagement metrics like time on page and conversion rate. A page with little traffic but high conversion can be more valuable than a page with lots of traffic that doesn’t convert.” — Barry Schwartz, SEO Expert and Journalist

Phase 3: Mapping and Assignment of New URLs

Now comes the core of the redirect strategy – mapping old to new URLs:

  1. Understanding the URL Structure of the New Website: Familiarize yourself with the URL architecture of the new website. This often changes fundamentally, e.g., from a flat to a hierarchical structure.
  2. 1:1 Mapping for Important Pages: For pages with high traffic or many backlinks, you should ideally create a direct equivalent on the new website.
  3. Category Mapping for Less Important Pages: For pages with lower value, it may be sufficient to redirect to the corresponding category or overview page.
  4. Consolidation of Similar Content: If multiple old pages on a similar topic exist, these can be redirected to a consolidated new page.
  5. Pattern Matching for Large Volumes: For websites with thousands of pages, you can identify patterns and create redirect rules (e.g., all URLs from /blog/2023/* to /magazine/2023/*).

The result of this phase is a complete mapping table that either assigns a new URL to each old URL or determines that the page is no longer needed.

Phase 4: Implementation Preparation and Quality Assurance

Before the redirects go live, some quality checks are required:

  1. Format Validation: Ensure that all old and new URLs are correctly formatted (absolute or relative, depending on the implementation method).
  2. Duplicate Check: Check if multiple old URLs should redirect to the same new URL (generally legitimate) or if an old URL appears multiple times in the list (generally an error).
  3. Redirect Chain Check: Ensure that no redirect chains are created by checking if new URLs already appear in the column of old URLs.
  4. Loop Check: Check if redirect loops could occur.
  5. Sample Tests: Test the redirect logic on examples before implementing everything.

After these checks, your redirect list is ready for implementation. How this is technically implemented depends heavily on your content management system and server infrastructure – that’s covered in the next section.

Special Scenarios in Mapping

In practice, special cases often arise that require specific attention:

Parameter URLs

URLs with parameters (e.g., ?filter=value) require special handling:

  • Check in Analytics whether parameter URLs receive organic traffic
  • If yes, create specific redirects for the most important variants
  • For all others, a rule at the pattern level may be sufficient

Seasonal or Campaign-Specific Content

For content that is temporarily relevant:

  • Expired campaigns: Usually redirect to similar current content or category pages
  • Seasonal content: If they recur annually, redirect to the corresponding new structure

Multilingual Websites

For websites with multiple language versions:

  • Ensure that redirects are language-specific (de to de, en to en)
  • Consider country coding in the mapping (e.g., /de-de/ to /de/)
  • Check if the hreflang implementation needs to be adjusted

With this systematic approach, your redirect list is now ready for technical implementation.

Implementing Redirects in Different Systems

The technical implementation of your carefully planned redirects depends heavily on your website infrastructure. Here we show you how to implement your redirect strategy in the most common systems.

Server-based Implementation

The server level offers the most powerful and flexible method for redirects. Depending on the server type, there are different approaches:

Apache Server (.htaccess)

On Apache servers, redirects are typically implemented in the .htaccess file:


# 301 Redirect for a specific URL
Redirect 301 /old-page.html https://www.example.com/new-page/

# Redirects with RegEx for patterns
RewriteEngine On
RewriteRule ^blog/([0-9]{4})/([0-9]{2})/(.*)$ /magazine/$1-$2/$3 [R=301,L]

For large numbers of redirects, you can use a script that converts your Excel list into .htaccess rules. Be sure to back up the file before making changes and test the rules in small batches.

Nginx Server

With Nginx, configuration is done in the server-block section of nginx.conf or in a separate configuration file:


server {
  listen 80;
  server_name example.com;

  # Individual redirect
  location = /old-page.html {
    return 301 https://www.example.com/new-page/;
  }

  # Pattern-based redirect
  location ~ ^/blog/([0-9]{4})/([0-9]{2})/(.*) {
    return 301 https://www.example.com/magazine/$1-$2/$3;
  }
}

Don’t forget to reload the server after changes to the configuration: sudo nginx -s reload

Implementation at CDN Level

For websites delivered via a Content Delivery Network (CDN), redirects can often be implemented at the CDN level:

  • Cloudflare: Via Page Rules or Bulk Redirects
  • Akamai: With EdgeScape and Property Manager
  • Fastly: Via VCL (Varnish Configuration Language)

The advantage: Redirects at the CDN level are executed before reaching your server, which offers performance benefits.

CMS-based Implementation

Many content management systems offer their own mechanisms for redirects:

WordPress

For WordPress there are several options:

  • Redirection Plugin: Ideal for small to medium websites, offers import from CSV, monitoring, and group management.
  • Yoast SEO Premium: Includes a redirect manager tool with CSV import.
  • Rank Math: The Pro version offers extensive redirect functions.

For larger WordPress sites (>500 redirects), a combination of plugin and .htaccess is often more efficient.

TYPO3

TYPO3 offers several options:

  • EXT:redirects: The core extension for redirects
  • site_manage_redirects: For complex redirect scenarios
  • CSV-Import: Via the import/export function

Shopify

In Shopify, you can set up redirects via the admin panel:

  1. Navigate to Online Store > Navigation > URL Redirects
  2. Use the “Import” button for bulk upload from CSV
  3. Shopify limits to 1,000 manual redirects – plan accordingly

Other CMS and Shop Systems

System Redirect Method Special Features
Drupal Redirect Module Supports bulk import, good performance
Joomla Redirectmanager Component Or via .htaccess for better performance
Magento URL Rewrite Management Integrated into Admin Panel
WooCommerce Via WordPress Plugins Special consideration for product URLs

Implementation Strategies for Large Websites

For websites with thousands of redirects, you should apply special strategies:

Rule-based vs. Exact Redirects

Instead of defining each URL individually, you can create rules based on patterns:

  • Advantages: Drastically reduces the number of rules, easier to maintain
  • Disadvantages: Less precise, can lead to unintended redirects
  • Best Practice: Combination of exact redirects for important URLs and rule-based redirects for the rest

Phased Implementation

For very large websites, a phased implementation is recommended:

  1. Phase 1: Implement and test highest priority URLs (Tier 1)
  2. Phase 2: Add Tier 2 URLs and test again
  3. Phase 3: Remaining URLs and pattern-based rules

This approach minimizes risks and ensures that the most important redirects work correctly.

Testing Before Going Live

Before the actual launch, you should thoroughly test your redirects:

  1. Staging Environment: First implement redirects on a staging server
  2. Header Inspection: Use tools like Redirection Checker or Chrome DevTools to check the HTTP headers
  3. Automated Testing: For large numbers of redirects, you can create scripts with Python/Curl that test all redirects
  4. Mobile Testing: Also check redirects on mobile devices

After implementation and thorough testing, your redirects are ready for go-live. But the process doesn’t end there – now begins the critical phase of monitoring.

Success Measurement and Monitoring After the Relaunch

Launching your website with implemented redirects is not the end, but the beginning of a critical phase: post-launch monitoring. This is where it’s determined whether your redirect strategy was successful or needs adjustment.

The First 48 Hours After Launch

The immediate time after the relaunch is crucial. Establish a “war room” setup with the following monitoring activities:

  • Server Log Analysis: Monitor 404 errors and unexpected redirect chains
  • Google Search Console Check: Observe if Google correctly recognizes the relaunch
  • User Feedback: Temporarily implement a feedback tool for users who encounter problems
  • Real-Time Analytics: Monitor traffic drops on specific pages or from specific sources

A common challenge in this phase: Distinguishing between normal launch fluctuations and real problems. A dashboard solution like Google Data Studio (now Looker Studio) or Tableau can help identify anomalies more quickly.

KPIs for Successful Redirects

Define clear metrics to measure the success of your redirect strategy:

KPI Target Value Measurement Method
404 Error Rate <1% of all pageviews Google Analytics, Search Console
Number of Crawled Redirects >90% of all implemented redirects Search Console, Server Logs
Organic Traffic (after 1 week) >80% of pre-relaunch traffic Analytics, especially landing pages
Crawling Efficiency No increase in Googlebot crawl time Search Console, Crawl Stats
Indexing Status (after 2 weeks) >90% of important pages indexed Site: query, Search Console

Bonus Tip: Create a snapshot of your most important rankings before launch with a tool like SEMrush or Sistrix. This way, you can specifically monitor whether certain keywords lose positions after the launch.

Error Analysis and Adjustment

Despite careful planning, problems can occur after the relaunch. Here’s a systematic approach to error analysis:

  1. Identify 404 Errors: Export from Search Console or Analytics all URLs causing 404 errors
  2. Look for Patterns: Are there structural commonalities among problematic URLs?
  3. Prioritize by Traffic: Fix errors first on URLs with the highest organic traffic or most backlinks
  4. Fix Implementation: Add missing redirects or correct faulty ones
  5. Re-Testing: Verify that the corrections are effective

A common cause of problems after relaunch: Parameter URLs or language-specific redirects that weren’t captured in the original crawl. Monitor the server logs especially closely in the first few weeks to identify such patterns.

“When dealing with redirect problems after a relaunch, it’s often more efficient to identify patterns and create generic rules than to manually fix each individual 404 URL. Look for common URL elements and create solutions at the structural level.” — Maria Fischer, Technical SEO Consultant

Long-Term Monitoring Strategy

A successful relaunch requires continuous monitoring that extends beyond the first few days:

  • Week 1-2: Daily check of all KPIs, quick response to problems
  • Week 3-4: Detailed analysis of rankings and organic traffic, comparison with pre-launch data
  • Month 2-3: Review of indexing rates, identification of slowly indexed areas
  • Month 4-6: Evaluation of overall performance, decision on possible adjustments to content strategy
  • From Month 7: Integration into regular SEO monitoring

Keep the redirects active for at least 12-18 months. Google representative John Mueller even recommends keeping critical redirects “forever” if possible.

Monitoring Tools and Dashboards

For effective post-launch monitoring, we recommend the following tools:

  • Google Search Console + Google Analytics: Basic setup for traffic and indexing monitoring
  • ContentKing or Sistrix: For daily monitoring of rankings and technical factors
  • Screaming Frog Monitor: For regular automated crawls and 404 detection
  • Looker Studio (formerly Google Data Studio): For a central dashboard that combines all KPIs
  • OnCrawl or Botify: For analyzing server logs and crawler behavior

A well-designed monitoring dashboard should include both technical and performance-related metrics and ideally enable daily, weekly, and monthly comparisons.

The investment in thorough post-launch monitoring pays off. Data from Brightedge shows that websites with structured post-relaunch monitoring return to their previous performance on average 37% faster than those without systematic monitoring.

Success Stories and Best Practices from the Field

Theoretical knowledge is valuable, but nothing is as convincing as real success stories. We’ve selected three case studies from our practice that illustrate different aspects of successful redirect strategies.

Case Study 1: Mid-sized B2B Industrial Equipment Supplier

Initial Situation: An industrial equipment supplier with over 5,000 product pages planned a complete relaunch with a new CMS and changed URL structure. Organic traffic accounted for 65% of total traffic and generated valuable leads.

Challenge: The old website had a flat URL structure, the new one should have a hierarchical category structure. Additionally, products were reclassified, requiring complex mapping decisions.

Solution:

  1. Complete crawl of the old website with Screaming Frog and integration of analytics data
  2. Prioritization based on traffic, backlinks, and conversions
  3. Creation of a ruleset for categories and subcategories
  4. Individual 1:1 mappings for the top 500 products by traffic
  5. Rule-based redirects for the remaining products
  6. Implementation via .htaccess with a staging test before launch

Result: After the relaunch, organic traffic initially dropped by only 12% and reached pre-launch levels again after 4 weeks. After 3 months, traffic was even 15% above the initial value. The conversion rate for product inquiries increased by 8%, which was attributable to the improved UX design.

Key Factor: The combination of precise 1:1 mappings for important pages and smart rule patterns for the rest enabled efficient implementation despite large URL volumes.

Case Study 2: Software-as-a-Service Provider with Domain Change

Initial Situation: A SaaS provider in the B2B sector was acquired and had to change its domain from oldcompany.com to newgroupcompany.com. The website had around 800 URLs and a strongly SEO-driven lead generation process.

Challenge: Besides the new domain, the language structure was also to be changed from /de/ and /en/ to country-specific subdomains (de.newgroupcompany.com, en.newgroupcompany.com).

Solution:

  1. Complete capture of all URLs including hreflang relationships
  2. Creation of a matrix for language and country variants
  3. Development of a special Excel template with validation of language-specific redirects
  4. Implementation via Nginx configuration
  5. Use of the Change of Address tool in Google Search Console
  6. Proactive notification of important backlink sources
  7. Extended monitoring over 12 months

Result: Organic traffic reached 85% of the original level after 8 weeks and 110% after 6 months. Particularly noteworthy: The bounce rate decreased by 18%, indicating an improved user journey.

Key Factor: The careful consideration of language variants and proactive communication with important backlink providers made the difference.

Case Study 3: E-Commerce Migration from Magento to Shopify

Initial Situation: A B2B retailer for office equipment with around 2,500 products migrated from Magento to Shopify. The shop generated 80% of the company’s revenue.

Challenge: Shopify uses a fundamentally different URL structure, and the migration function didn’t cover all required redirects. Additionally, Shopify limits manual redirects to 1,000.

Solution:

  1. Data extraction from Magento and traffic analysis for prioritization
  2. Creation of a two-stage redirect plan:
    • Top 1,000 URLs via Shopify Redirect Manager
    • Remaining URLs via a Shopify app “Bulk Redirects”
  3. Special attention to filter functions and category combinations
  4. Implementation of a custom 404 handler for URLs not explicitly mapped
  5. Gradual migration over a weekend with live monitoring

Result: Organic traffic reached pre-launch levels again after just 3 weeks. The conversion rate increased by 12%, partly due to the improved Shopify checkout experience. After 6 months, SEO traffic was 25% above the initial value.

Key Factor: The combination of manual high-priority redirects and the intelligent custom 404 handler, which automatically redirected unmapped URLs to the most suitable category.

Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

From our experience with over 50 relaunches, we’ve identified the most common mistakes that you should definitely avoid:

  1. Incomplete URL Collection: Many companies only capture the obvious URLs, but miss important subpages.

    Solution: Combine multiple data sources (crawler, analytics, Search Console, backlink tools).
  2. Neglect of Non-HTML Content: PDFs, images, and other files are often overlooked.

    Solution: Make sure your crawler captures these contents as well and prioritize them by backlinks.
  3. Redirect Chains: When old redirects aren’t cleaned up, chains develop.

    Solution: Check before the relaunch if existing redirects exist and update them directly to the new destination.
  4. Redirects to the Homepage: Out of convenience, many unassigned URLs are simply redirected to the homepage.

    Solution: Redirect to thematically matching subpages or create a special landing page for frequently visited deleted content.
  5. Time Pressure at Launch: Often redirects are hastily implemented at the last minute.

    Solution: Start redirect planning early, ideally in parallel with the conception of the new website.

Expert-Level Tips for Special Scenarios

For advanced users, we have some special tips:

Internationalization and hreflang

If your website has different language versions:

  • Create a separate redirect matrix for each language version
  • Update hreflang annotations according to the new URL structure
  • Test language detection and redirection after the relaunch

Using Canonical Tags as a Complementary Strategy

In some cases, the combination of redirects and canonical tags can be useful:

  • For parameter URLs: Redirect for the most important ones, canonical for rarely used variants
  • For seasonal content: Temporary redirect + permanent canonical
  • For content consolidation: Merge similar content with canonical to the main version

Progressive Enhancement for Large Websites

For very large websites with tens of thousands of URLs:

  • Implement a “progressive enhancement” model: Start with the top 20% by traffic/value
  • Observe 404 errors in the server logs and add redirects based on real usage data
  • Use machine learning to identify URL patterns in 404 requests

These case studies and best practices demonstrate: With a structured approach and the right Excel template as a foundation, even complex relaunch scenarios can be successfully mastered.

Conclusion and Recommendations

A website relaunch without a well-thought-out redirect strategy is like jumping into cold water without a life preserver – risky and potentially costly. As we’ve seen, a flawed redirect process can lead to significant traffic losses, while a well-planned strategy makes the transition seamless and can even serve as a springboard for better performance.

Summary of Key Insights

Let’s summarize the central points of this guide once more:

  • Business Relevance: A missing or inadequate redirect strategy can lead to traffic losses of 50-70% and requires months for recovery – with direct impact on leads and revenue.
  • Technical Foundation: 301 redirects are the gold standard for relaunches and transfer 95-99% of SEO value, while redirect chains and loops should be avoided at all costs.
  • Structured Process: Success lies in a systematic approach – from complete URL collection through data-based prioritization to careful mapping and continuous monitoring.
  • Implementation Variety: Depending on technical infrastructure, various implementation paths are available – from .htaccess through CMS plugins to CDN solutions.
  • Post-Launch Phase: Monitoring after the relaunch is crucial for long-term success and should be actively conducted for at least 3-6 months.

Checklist for an SEO-friendly Relaunch

To conclude, a practical checklist that can accompany you through your next relaunch:

  1. Preparation Phase (1-3 months before launch)
    • Create complete URL inventory (crawl + analytics + Search Console)
    • Collect SEO performance data (rankings, traffic, conversions)
    • Conduct backlink analysis
    • Finalize URL structure of the new website
    • Prepare Excel template for redirect list
  2. Mapping Phase (3-6 weeks before launch)
    • Prioritize by traffic, backlinks, and business value
    • Create 1:1 mappings for Tier-1 URLs
    • Category mappings for less important URLs
    • Define rule-based redirect patterns for the rest
    • Quality Assurance: Check for redirect chains and loops
  3. Implementation Phase (1-2 weeks before launch)
    • Select technical implementation method
    • Test redirects on staging environment
    • Set up monitoring (Analytics, Search Console, Logs)
    • Create pre-launch snapshots (rankings, traffic)
    • Define emergency plan for critical issues
  4. Launch Phase
    • Implement redirects
    • Update XML sitemap and submit in Search Console
    • For domain changes: Use Change of Address tool
    • Conduct sample tests
    • Check server logs for 404 errors
  5. Post-Launch Phase
    • Intensive monitoring in the first 48 hours
    • Identify and fix 404 errors
    • Weekly performance checks (first 4 weeks)
    • Make adjustments based on usage and crawling data
    • Long-term monitoring for at least 3-6 months

Your Next Steps

A successful relaunch begins with the right preparation. Here are your recommended next steps:

  1. Download Template: Download our SEO Redirect Template 2025 and adapt it to your needs.
  2. Start Inventory: Begin with a complete crawl of your existing website – the earlier, the better.
  3. Obtain Expertise: For complex relaunches or limited internal resources, external support can be valuable. Our website performance team has years of experience with successful relaunches.
  4. Create Monitoring Plan: Define in advance how you will measure the success of your relaunch – including KPIs and reporting rhythm.

“The true success of a relaunch is shown not on the day of publication, but in the weeks and months afterward. Careful planning of your redirect strategy is not a waste of time, but an investment in the continuity of your digital business success.” — Tim Berners-Lee, Inventor of the World Wide Web

With the right Excel template, a systematic approach, and continuous monitoring, your next relaunch will not be a risk to your SEO performance, but a springboard for your digital growth.

Do you have questions about your specific relaunch project? Our team is happy to help. Contact us for a no-obligation consultation.

Frequently Asked Questions About SEO Redirects

How long should redirects remain active after a relaunch?

Redirects should ideally remain active for at least 12-18 months after a relaunch. Google’s John Mueller even recommends keeping important redirects “forever”. The reason: Search engines crawl some pages very rarely, and external backlinks or bookmarks may still reference old URLs years later. For particularly important pages with many backlinks, redirects should be implemented permanently. Premature removal can lead to 404 errors and jeopardize the SEO value you’ve built up.

When should I use 302 redirects instead of 301 redirects?

302 redirects (temporary redirects) should only be used in certain scenarios where the redirection is actually time-limited. Typical use cases are:

  • A/B tests, where users are temporarily directed to different versions of a page
  • Seasonal campaigns or time-limited offers
  • Maintenance work, where users are temporarily redirected to a status page
  • Geolocated redirects that can change depending on user location

For a website relaunch, 302 redirects are generally not suitable, as they transfer significantly less SEO value (approx. 50-60% compared to 95-99% with 301 redirects) and signal to search engines that the change is only temporary.

How do I handle URLs that don’t have direct equivalents on the new website?

When URLs don’t have direct 1:1 equivalents on the new website, there are several strategic approaches:

  1. Redirect to the thematically closest page: Identify the most content-relevant new page and redirect there. This is often the best option for SEO value transfer.
  2. Redirect to the parent category: If no direct thematic replacement exists, redirect to the corresponding category page that covers the topic.
  3. Re-creation of important content: For pages with many backlinks or high traffic, you should consider creating similar content on the new website.
  4. Custom 404 page with recommendations: As a last option, you can create a customized 404 page that suggests relevant alternatives. However, this should only be considered for content with very low value.

The decision should be based on data: The more traffic and backlinks a page has, the more important it is to find a good redirect solution instead of risking a 404 error.

How do redirects affect my website’s loading speed?

Redirects can affect your website’s loading speed, as each redirect requires an additional HTTP request. According to Google data, each redirect adds about 300-500 milliseconds to loading time. This quickly adds up, especially on mobile devices with slower connections.

To minimize the performance impact:

  • Avoid redirect chains (multiple consecutive redirects)
  • Update internal links directly to the new URL structure
  • Implement redirects at the server level instead of via JavaScript
  • Use HTTP/2 or HTTP/3 to reduce redirect latency
  • Implement CDN-based redirects for faster processing

After a relaunch, you should regularly update internal links to reduce the number of redirects in the long term and improve loading speed.

What are the most common mistakes when implementing redirects?

The five most common mistakes when implementing redirects after a relaunch are:

  1. Wrong Redirect Types: Using 302 (temporary) instead of 301 (permanent) redirects for a relaunch, leading to less SEO value transfer.
  2. Redirect Chains: When redirects are chained consecutively (A→B→C), you lose SEO value with each step and increase loading time.
  3. Generic Redirects to the Homepage: Instead of choosing thematically appropriate target pages, all unassigned URLs are redirected to the homepage – a suboptimal signal for search engines.
  4. Incomplete URL Collection: Important URLs are overlooked in the mapping, especially non-HTML content like PDFs or images with backlinks.
  5. Missing Post-Launch Monitoring: After implementation, there is no systematic monitoring of whether redirects are functioning correctly and if 404 errors are occurring.

These mistakes can be avoided through structured planning, a complete URL inventory, and systematic testing before and after launch. In more complex cases, support from SEO experts with relaunch experience can be useful.

How much SEO value is lost with a 301 redirect?

According to current Google statements (as of 2024), 301 redirects transfer about 95-99% of the SEO value of the original page. This is a significant improvement over earlier estimates that assumed a loss of 10-15%.

John Mueller from Google has confirmed that 301 redirects today “transfer almost the full PageRank value.” Nevertheless, some nuanced factors can negatively impact:

  • Content relevance between source and target page (the less thematic match, the higher the potential value loss)
  • Redirect chains (each additional hop in a chain can cost 5-10% value)
  • Changes in content quality or length
  • Use of canonicals together with redirects (can lead to interpretation problems)

Empirical studies from SEMrush and Ahrefs confirm that with correctly implemented 301 redirects, the SEO impact is minimal and rankings are typically fully restored within 2-4 weeks.

What special considerations are there for international websites during a relaunch?

International websites require special attention in several areas during a relaunch:

  1. Language-specific Redirects: Ensure that redirects are language-congruent (German pages to German pages, English to English, etc.).
  2. hreflang Implementation: Update all hreflang tags to reflect the new URL structure. This is critical to show search engines the correct language version for different markets.
  3. Geolocated Redirects: If your website redirects users based on their location, this logic must be compatible with the new URL structure.
  4. Geotargeting in Search Console: When using subdomains or subdirectories for different countries, the geotargeting settings in Google Search Console must be updated.
  5. Country-specific Backlinks: Analyze backlinks by country and prioritize redirects for URLs that have strong local backlinks.
  6. IP Delivery Systems: If your website delivers content based on IP addresses, this must be aligned with your redirect strategy.

A proven approach is to create separate redirect matrices for each language version, with own prioritizations based on local performance. Additionally, post-launch monitoring should be done by country, as crawling speed can vary in different regions.

How do I handle very large amounts of redirects for websites with thousands of URLs?

For websites with thousands or tens of thousands of URLs, the redirect strategy requires a scalable approach:

  1. Pattern-based Redirects: Identify URL patterns and create rewrite rules instead of individual redirects. Example: All URLs under /product/XXXX/ are redirected to /shop/XXXX/.
  2. Prioritization by Data: Divide URLs into tiers based on traffic, backlinks, and business value:
    • Tier 1 (Top 5-10%): Individual redirects with manual verification
    • Tier 2 (15-20%): Semi-automated redirects with sample checks
    • Tier 3 (Rest): Rule-based redirects
  3. Automated Mapping Tools: Use tools like Screaming Frog SEO Spider (Bulk URL Mapping) or special Python scripts to automate mapping.
  4. Server Optimization: With very large redirect lists, performance can suffer. Solutions:
    • Implementation at CDN level
    • Use of rewrite maps in Apache/Nginx
    • Use of database-based redirect systems instead of static files
  5. Progressive Deployment: Implement redirects in phases, starting with the most important URLs.

Modern enterprise SEO platforms like Botify or Conductor offer special functions for large relaunch projects, including automated mapping, validation, and monitoring. For particularly large websites (>100,000 URLs), a custom redirect API solution can also be developed that dynamically manages redirects.

How does using a new domain affect the redirect strategy?

A domain change (e.g., from oldcompany.com to newcompany.com) significantly increases the complexity of your redirect strategy and requires additional measures:

  1. Change of Address Tool: Make sure to use the Change of Address tool in Google Search Console to officially inform Google about the domain change.
  2. Domain-wide 301 Redirects: Implement redirects not just for individual pages, but also at the root domain level.
  3. DNS TTL Adjustments: Reduce the TTL (Time to Live) of your DNS entries before the change to enable faster propagation.
  4. Cross-Domain Analytics: Configure analytics for cross-domain tracking to understand user flow between old and new domains.
  5. Proactive Backlink Update: Contact websites with valuable backlinks and ask for updates to the new domain.
  6. Extended Monitoring Period: Plan for 12-18 months (instead of 3-6) for complete restoration of visibility.
  7. Google Business Profile: Update your Google Business Profile and other local directories.
  8. Social Media and Brand Assets: Update all profiles and visual assets with the new domain.

Particularly important: Keep the old domain active with functioning redirects for at least 1-2 years. According to a study by Moz (2024), domain migrations need an average of 1.7 times longer for complete restoration of visibility than normal relaunches on the same domain. The ROI of a comprehensive redirect strategy is therefore particularly high for domain changes.

Which tools are best suited for testing redirects?

For systematic testing of redirects before and after a relaunch, there are various specialized tools:

  • For manual tests of individual URLs:
    • Redirect Checker (https://redirectcheck.com) – Shows the complete redirect chain
    • httpstatus.io – Checks status codes and headers
    • Chrome DevTools (Network Tab) – For detailed analysis of requests
  • For bulk tests of many URLs:
    • Screaming Frog SEO Spider – List Mode with “Always Follow Redirects” option
    • Sitebulb – Redirect Audit Feature
    • ContentKing – Real-time monitoring of redirects
    • Python scripts with Requests library for custom tests
  • For continuous monitoring:
    • Sentry – For real-time notifications of 404 errors
    • Geckoboard or Databox – For redirect monitoring dashboards
    • Google Analytics 404 tracking – With event tracking for 404 errors
    • Airbrake – For exception tracking including redirect errors

For enterprise websites, a combination of automated tests and sample checks is recommended. A proven process is: 1) Automated tests of all redirects in the staging environment, 2) Manual verification of high-priority URLs, 3) Setting up continuous monitoring after launch with notifications for critical errors.

Takeaways

  • The opportunity to focus on more complex tasks emerges early on.
  • Developing versatility will undoubtedly be a key to success.
  • Emotional intelligence will help fulfill a sense of competence.